Menu of Pultneyville Deli Co
Best food in Williamson
Open
Your order will be confirmed in REAL-TIME
Table Reservation
See MENU & Order
Online menu of Pultneyville Deli Co
LOBSTER ROLLS & SPRING SPECIALS-CHECK OUT OUR NEW $12 MENU FROM 3-6PM
Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich
From 14.99
Crispy chicken, kissed with Casey's hot honey glaze, topped with creamy coleslaw, pickles, on grilled ciabatta, with 1 side
Apples, Cheddar & Roasted Chicken Flatbread Panini
From 14.99
Crisp Apples, Roasted Chicken, Fresh Spinach, Red Onion & Melted Cheddar, on warm Flatbread served with choice of side (fries, buttered corn, baked beans. coleslaw, mac salad or chips)
Grilled Fish Sandwich
From 13.99
Grilled tilapia filet, lettuce, tomato, on a warm hard roll, served with choice of side
Mediterranean Veggie Panini
From 14.99
Spinach, Tomato, Red Onion & Roasted Red Peppers, Provolone, grilled & pressed on choice of sourdough, marble rye or multigrain bread, served with choice of side (fries, coleslaw, mac salad, baked beans, buttered corn, chips)
Chicken Caesar Wrap, served with fries or a homemade side
From 14.99
House-roasted chicken in our caesar dressing, with parmesan cheese and romaine, folded into your choice of spinach, wheat or flour wrap & served with fries, cole slaw or mac salad
GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST SANDWICH
From 13.99
Marinated & Grilled, lettuce tomato, warm ciabatta, choice of one side (mayo on request)
1/2 LB BACON CHEESEBURGER
From 15.99
1/2 lb brisket/angus mix, A,erican cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, on a freshly-baked ciabatta roll, fries or choice of side
SHRIMP BASKET-NEW!
From 12.99
5-6 Large Shrimp, Fries or a homemade side, & our house recipe tartar sauce. Great for a picnic!
Ultimate Grilled Cheese
From 14.99
A trio of Cheddar, Swiss & Provolone cheeses, add tomatoes & bacon, and grilled between thick slices of sourdough, multigrain or marble rye, served with choice of side
Fried Clam Strips Meal
From 17.99
Tender meaty fries clams (1/2 lb) served with tartar sauce and choice of side
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
From 14.99
Choice of roasted or crispy chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing, choice of wrap (flour, spinach or wheat) served with choice of 1 side
LOBSTER ROLLS ARE BACK! New England (Traditional) or Hot Buttered -starting April 3
From 16.99
New England Lobster Roll-This is the traditional lobster roll, 55% lobster, mixed with a touch of mayo and our secret seasonings, piled into a grilled New England Ciabatta roll
HOT BUTTERED LOBSTER ROLL
From 24.99
1/4 LB of 100% Lobster meat, quickly sauteed with butter, a sprinkle of dill, and a squeeze of fresh lemon, piled into a grilled New England-style ciabatta roll
$12 COMPLETE DINNERS FROM 3PM-6PM. Online Ordering available 2pm-6pm, Wed-Sun
Shrimp Basket
12.00
5-6 Large shrimp, flash-fried & served with fries or one side. Check out our other $12 meals, available from 3pm-6pm Wed-Sun
$12 COMPLETE DINNERS FROM 3PM-6PM WEDNESDAY THRU SUNDAY
Specialty Chicken-Topped Mac & Cheese Dinners
12.00
1/2 lb of our homemade Mac & Cheese, Topped with 1/4 lb of our house recipe BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken or Chipotle Chicken. Our #1 seller.
Crispy Chicken Sandwich or Wrap
From 12.00
Breaded Chicken Breast, topped with lettuce & tomato, on a freshly-baked hard roll or a wrap, with your choice of side
Personal Flatbread Pizza-choice of topping
From 12.00
Our popular flatbread pizza, finished in our pizza oven, with choice of one topping. (Extra Toppings are $3 each)
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
From 12.00
Crispy Chicken, smothered with Casey's Buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, on your choice of wrap (white, wheat or spinach) with choice of one side
Tuna Melt
From 12.00
Freshly-prepared premium tuna, swiss cheese, tomato, grilled on multigrain bread with your choice of side
Shrimp Po Boy
From 12.00
Four large shrimp, breaded and fried, served on a fresh hoagie roll, with lettuce, tomato and Chef Tim's po-boy sauce
Steamed Mussels (1 lb)
From 12.00
A full pound of mussels, steamed in a touch of garlic butter, served with a slab of garlic bread and choice of a side
Philly Cheesesteak
From 12.00
Steak with grilled onions & peppers & melted provolone, stuffed inside a freshly-baked 6-inch hoagie roll, with you choice of side
MAC & CHEESE IS BACK!
BAKED MAC & CHEESE-OUR FAMOUS MAC & CHEESE IS BACK!
From 6.99
A creamy blend of rich cheeses & subtle seasonings, baked to perfection, as a meal or available in a smaller portion with any sandwich or entree
BBQ PORK MAC & CHEESE
12.99
1/2 lb portion of our famous mac & cheese, topped with 1/4 lb of our house-smoked BBQ pork. Comfort food at its best!
BBQ CHICKEN MAC & CHEESE
12.99
1/2 lb of mac & cheese, topped with another 1/4 lb of BBQ chicken, finished on the grill. Hearty & delicious!
CHIPOTLE CHICKEN MAC & CHEESE
12.99
Our famous chipotle chicken tops 1/2 lb or creamy mac & cheese
BUFFALO CHICKEN MAC & CHEESE
12.99
1/2 lb of our homemade Mac & Cheese, topped with 1/4 lb of our grilled buffalo chicken
FRIDAY FISH FRY*ALL DAY LONG*BEST FISH FRY IN TOWN!
FRIDAYS ONLY-FISH FRY DINNER
From 16.99
Our beer-battered haddock filet served with our homemade cole slaw & fries-tartar sauce & lemon on request
Breakfast Sandwiches-Served 11am-12pm SATURDAYS & SUNDAYS
ALL AMERICAN
From 9.00
fried egg, hash browns, American cheese, bacon, ham or sausage on a grilled ciabatta roll
BREAKFAST HOAGIE (6")
From 14.00
p'ville sausage patty, scrambled egg, bar sauce, grilled peppers & onions, pepper-jack cheese, fresh hoagie roll
BREAKFAST B.L.T.
From 9.00
egg any style with bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on a bagel or grilled ciabatta roll
RISE & SHINE
From 9.00
Fried egg, turkey, swiss cheese, roasted red peppers and mayonnaise on a bagel or grilled ciabatta roll
Breakfast Steak Sandwich
From 12.00
An egg your way, shaved steak, grilled peppers & onions, topped with cheese on choice of grilled ciabatta roll or bagel
VEGGIE BREAKFAST SANDWICH
From 9.00
An egg, Amercian cheese, hashbrowns, choice of (1) veggie, grilled ciabatta roll or bagel
BREAKFAST BOWLS-BIG ENOUGH FOR ANY APPETITE-WEEKENDS FROM 11am-12pm
DELI BREAKFAST BOWL
From 12.00
2 eggs, American cheese, choice of bacon, ham, sausage or turkey, potatoes
GREEK BREAKFAST BOWL-(vegetarian)
From 12.00
2 eggs, feta cheese, grilled onions & peppers, potatoes
VEGGIE BREAKFAST BOWL
From 12.00
2 eggs, American cheese, choice of up to 2 veggies, potatoes
WESTERN BREAKFAST BOWL
From 12.00
A western omelet in a big bowl-2 eggs, ham, cheddar, grilled onions & peppers, potatoes
PHILLY STEAK BREAKFAST BOWL
From 14.50
2 eggs, steak, grilled onions & peppers, potatoes
TEXAS BREAKFAST BOWL
From 13.00
2 eggs, Country-fried steak, hash browns or fries, topped with our homemade sausage gravy
TRASH PLATE BREAKFAST BOWL
From 13.00
2 eggs, American cheese, potatoes, our own meat hot sauce
GOURMET PIZZAS
PERSONAL FLATBREAD PIZZA
From 12.99
flat bread, pizza sauce, mozzarella. additional charge for extra toppings
BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA
From 22.99
pulled chicken pepper jack, mozzarella, red onion, cilantro, homemade sweet bbq sauce
THE WORKS
From 22.99
sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, black olives, mozzarella, marinara sauce
FRESH TOMATO PESTO
From 22.99
fresh spinach, bacon, fresh tomato slices, parmesan, mozzarella, pesto sauce
VEGGIE PIZZA
From 22.99
artichoke hearts, black olives, portabella mushrooms, red onion, mozzarella, marinara sauce
BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA
From 22.99
pulled chicken, medium buffalo sauce, crumbly blue, mozzarella, dried celery
MEAT LOVERS
From 22.99
pepperoni, italian sausage, bacon, ham, mozzarella, marinara sauce
CREATE YOUR OWN PIZZA
From 18.99
Start with mozzarella on top of white garlic or classic marinara sauce-additional toppings extra
SPECIALTY BURGERS
CLASSIC BURGER
From 13.99
mayo, romaine, tomato, red onion
PHILLY BURGER
From 15.99
shaved steak, mozzarella cheese, onions, peppers and steak sauce
BLACK AND BLUE BURGER
From 15.99
sauteed onions, crumble blue cheese, romaine and tomato
TEX-MEX BURGER
From 15.99
pepper jack cheese, corn salsa, chipotle mayo
COWBOY BURGER
From 15.99
american cheese, bbq sauce, onion rings
BEYOND BURGER
From 14.99
plant based burger, lettuce, tomato and onion
PUB BURGER
From 15.99
Piled with bacon, ham, cheddar cheese, chipotle mayo, lettuce & tomato
Mushroom Swiss Burger
From 15.99
Grilled portobellos, melted swiss cheese, garnished with lettuce & tomato, on a freshly-baked ciabatta roll
Bacon Cheeseburger
From 15.99
Bacon & melted American cheese, lettuce, tomato, piled on our 1/2 lb Angus burger, on a fresh ciabatta roll
PREMIUM SALADS
COBB SALAD
From 14.99
Choose either turkey or ham, with bacon, crumbled blue cheese, hardboiled egg, tomato, balsamic vinaigrette
CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD
From 13.99
chicken, parmesan, house-made croutons, caesar dressing
WALDORF SALAD
From 13.99
chicken salad (walnuts, craisins, apple, celery, red onion), tomato, red onion, balsamic vinaigrette
SPINACH SALAD
From 14.99
spinach, hardboiled egg, mushrooms, warm bacon, balsamic vinaigrette
TACO SALAD
From 15.99
seasoned ground beef, tomato, tortilla chips, cheddar cheese, salsa and sour cream
CALYPSO SALAD
From 13.99
chicken, glazed walnuts, feta cheese, craisins, cucumber, balsamic vinaigrette
SOUTHWEST SALAD
From 13.99
chicken, sweet corn salsa, tomatoes, crunchy tortilla chips, cheddar cheese, salsa, buttermilk ranch
GARDNER-Create your own salad on a bed of fresh greens
From 12.99
your choice of 3 non-meat toppings-extra charge for chicken, bacon, extra toppings or other meat items
DELI SANDWICHES-Served with choice of side & a pickle.
CHIPOTLE CHICKEN MELT
From 14.99
roasted & shredded chicken, bacon, cheddar cheese, tomato, spicy chipotle mayonnaise, grilled sourdough
CLUB
From 14.99
turkey or ham, with bacon, cheddar cheese, romaine, tomato, mayo, warm flat bread
LOADED CHICKEN SALAD
From 14.99
chicken, walnuts, apple, celery, red onion, craisins, mayo, romaine, tomato, warm flatbread
CHICKEN PESTO WRAP
From 14.99
roasted chicken, basil pesto, red onions, roasted red peppers, melted provolone, parmesan, spinach wrap
PHILLY OR CHICKEN CHEESE STEAK
From 14.99
grilled steak or chicken or turkey, onions, peppers, melted provolone cheese, on a freshly-baked Italian sub roll
BLACKENED FISH REUBEN
From 15.99
grilled tilapia, asian slaw, swiss cheese, zesty citrus sauce, grilled marbled rye
GRILLED OR CRISPY CHICKEN BREAST
From 13.99
chicken breast, romaine, tomato, red onion, grilled hard roll (cheese additional)
CHICKEN TENDER SUB
From 13.99
breaded chicken tenders, mayo, romaine, tomato
CORNED BEEF REUBEN OR TURKEY REUBEN
From 15.99
corned beef, swiss cheese, your choice of coleslaw or sauerkraut, 1000 island dressing, grilled marble rye
BEEF 'N BLUE
From 16.99
roast beef, crumbled blue cheese, tomato, red onion, creamy horseradish sauce, grilled sourdough
Tuna Melt
From 13.99
Freshly-prepared tuna, swiss cheese, tomato, grilled multi grain bread
B.L.T
From 13.99
applewood-smoked bacon, romaine, tomato, warm flat bread
TURKEY CRANBERRY
From 13.99
roasted turkey, creamy cranberry sauce, cucumber, romaine, multigrain bread
VEGGIE SANDWICH
From 14.99
grilled portobello mushroom, roasted red peppers, feta cheese, spinach, balsamic vinaigrette, grilled ciabatta roll
CALYPSO CHICKEN WRAP
From 13.99
chicken, romaine, glazed walnuts, feta cheese, cucumber, balsamic vinaigrette, choice of wrap
MEATBALL SUB
From 14.99
meatballs, marinara and mozzarella cheese
Shrimp Po-Boy
From 14.99
Large Shrimp, drizzled with Casey';s homemade Po-boy sauce, topped with lettuce, tomato, on a freshly-baked sub roll, served with 1 side
PORK CUBAN
From 15.99
House-smoked pulled pork, smoked ham, coleslaw, pickles, creamy dijon mustard, grilled ciabatta roll
TEX MEX PANINI WRAP
From 14.99
Roasted chicken, cheddar, chipotle mayo, lettuce, sweet corn salsa, pressed & grilled on choice of wrap
PULLED PORK SANDWICH
From 15.99
House-smoked pulled pork, a drizzle of Casey's BBQ sauce, topped with our creamy homemade coleslaw, nestled in a soft bun
HOT HONEY CHICKEN- OUR TAKE ON A SOUTHERN FAVORITE
From 14.99
Crispy chicken breast topped drizzled with our hot honey glaze, topped with homemade creamy coleslaw & finished on top with pickles, nesled on a freshly-baked hard roll, comes with choice of side
Kids Menu-For Kids 10 and under please. $8.99 & up
KIDS CHEESE PIZZA
From 9.99
pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese. includes one kid's side - extra toppings add $3 each, substitutions extra
KIDS CHICKEN TENDERS
From 8.99
2 breaded chicken tenders with your choice of one dipping sauce, one kid's side
KIDS GRILLED CHEESE
From 8.99
Grilled American cheese-sourdough bread & 1 kid's side (extra charge for substitutions)
KIDS MAC & CHEESE
From 8.99
Kid's portion of Mac & Cheese, with choice of 1 kid's side (Apple slices, chips or corn)
SEAFOOD DINNERS
FRIED SHRIMP DINNER
From 15.99
A generous portion of shrimp, butterflied, battered and fried, served with choice of 2 sides. Tartar sauce or cocktail sauce on request.
FRIED CLAM ROLL
From 14.99
A quarter pound of meaty clam strips, fried to perfection. Served New England-style on a roll, with a side of tartar sauce. Comes with fries or choice of one side.
FRIED CLAM DINNER
From 17.99
A half-pound portion of thick clam strips, battered and fried, served with choice of 1 side
FRIDAY FISH FRY-Fridays Only
From 16.99
1/2 lb+ premium beer-battered haddock filet, served with fries and our home made coleslaw
MUSSELS IN GARLIC & WHITE WINE
From 13.99
A full pound, sauteed in butter, garlic & white wine, served with a slab of hot garlic bread for dipping. Add a side and make it a dinner for $3.
Traditional Lobster Roll Dinner
From 22.99
New England style lobster roll (our homemade lobster salad piled into a warm New England brioche bun) served with choice of 2 sides (fries, coleslaw, mac salad, applesauce, chips or baked beans)
HOT BUTTERED LOBSTER ROLL DINNER
From 24.99
1/4 lb of fresh lobster meat, quickly poached in hot butter, served with choice of side
From The Fryer
PIZZA LOGS
9.99
3 pizza logs served with side of marinara
CALAMARI SICILIANO
14.99
Delicate Calamari, flash-fried and topped with roasted red peppers and banana peppers, served with our marinara sauce
CHICKEN TENDERS
From 11.99
Our delicious chicken tenders, served with choice of one housemade dipping sauce
SWEET POTATO FRIES
From 6.99
Thick wedges of sweet potatoes, deep-fried & delicious! Served with choice of dipping sauce
SPICY PICKLE FRIES
From 11.99
breaded pickles served with your choice of dipping sauce.
Onion Rings
From 7.99
Beer-battered onion rings, choice of dipping sauce
Beverages & Adult Beverages
Coffee
2.75
Freshly ground, locally roasted
Iced Coffee
3.75
16 oz. of freshly-brewed iced coffee, from locally roasted beans
Coca Cola Products 20 oz.
2.89
Coke, Diet Coke, Coke Zero, Canada Dry Ginger Ale, Sprite, Diet Sprite, Barq's Rootbeer
Peace Tea-23 oz
2.89
Georgia Peach, Razzleberry, Snoberry, Caddyshack
Dasani Spring Water-20 oz
2.89
Fairlife Organic Milk
2.89
Regular, Chocolate, Strawberry
Vitamin Water-20 0z
2.89
xxx acai-blueberry-pomegranate, xxx zero acai-blueberry-pomegranate
A & W Products-24 oz
2.89
Root Beer, Diet Root Beer, Cream Soda
Stewart's Original Fountain Classics-12 oz glass bottle
2.89
Root Beer, Diet Root Beer, Birch Beer, Orange n Cream, Diet Orange, Grape
Celsius "Healthy Energy Drink"
3.59
Celsius Energy Drink-12 oz can-Assorted Flavors-zero sugar,
Dr Pepper, Diet Dr. Pepper- 20 oz bottle
2.89
Minute Maid Pink Lemonade or Lemonade- 20 oz bottle
2.89
Iced Coffee
3.75
16 oz. of freshly-brewed iced coffee, from locally roasted beans
HOMEMADE SIDES
Fries
5.49
Shoestring potatoes, deep-fried and delicious
Coleslaw
5.49
Our famous house recipe coleslaw
Corn
5.49
Sweet kernel corn with a hint of butter
Mac Salad
5.49
Homemade daily
Dinner Side Salad
5.99
Fresh greens, tomato, onion & choice of dressing
Baked Beans
5.49
Savory & Sweet-our secret recipe
Onion Rings
7.99
Deep-fried, served with choice of dipping sauce
SWEET POTATO FRIES
6.99
A generous portion of sweet potato wedges, deep-fried, with choice of dipping sauce. (Try some buttermilk ranch or our hot honey glaze with these beauties!)
BAKED WHITE CHEDDAR MAC & CHEESE
From 6.99
Casey's homemade white-cheddar mac & cheese